Advocate Mohammad Kamran
- 10+ Years of Legal Experience
- Enrolled with the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh
- Certificate of Practice holder
GST Notice Reply Assistance in Lucknow
Answering departmental correspondence under GST, from a mismatch query to a show-cause notice.
Tax and GST
What this covers
GST notices arrive for a limited number of recurring reasons. A difference between two of a business's own filings. Input tax credit claimed that does not appear in the supplier's filings. Returns not filed. A view taken by the department on classification or valuation. A proposal to cancel the registration. Each of these is answered differently, and the first step is to identify from the notice itself what is actually being alleged and under which provision.
These are legal proceedings, not accounting correspondence, and they run to timelines. A reply is generally required within a stated period, and where a show-cause notice is not answered the matter proceeds on the material the department has. Because an adjudication order carries a right of appeal with its own conditions, what is placed on the record at the reply stage shapes everything that follows.
Scope of assistance
What this work involves, and what it does not
Different parts of a matter of this kind are different kinds of work. This is how they divide.
- Legal advisoryAdvice on the legal position, the options open and the consequences of each.
- Document draftingPreparation and review of the agreements, deeds and written replies the matter requires.
- Response and representation before an authorityWritten replies and appearance before the authority concerned, where an advocate may act as authorised representative.
- Coordination with other professionalsWhere a matter requires audit, or a certificate or filing that only a specified professional may sign, it is coordinated with a chartered accountant or company secretary.
Nothing on this page is an offer to audit accounts or to issue any certificate that only a chartered accountant or company secretary may issue. No professional designation is claimed for anyone at the firm beyond enrolment as an advocate, and no undertaking is given that any particular person will certify, audit or appear in a given matter.
Who this may assist
Who this service may assist
If your situation is not listed, it does not mean it cannot be dealt with. It means it should be discussed.
-
Businesses that have received a show-cause notice
A notice proposing a demand or an adverse order has been issued.
-
Businesses facing a credit reversal
Input tax credit has been questioned or proposed to be reversed.
-
Businesses with a mismatch query
The department has raised a difference between filings.
-
Businesses facing cancellation
A notice proposing cancellation of registration has been issued.
Scope
Assistance available
- Reading the notice and identifying what is alleged, under which provision, and by when a reply is due
- Drafting replies to show-cause and other departmental notices, with the documents indexed against each allegation
- Submissions on credit, classification and valuation questions
- Replies to notices proposing cancellation of registration
- Representation before the adjudicating and appellate authorities as authorised representative
- Appeals against adjudication orders, and coordination with a chartered accountant on reconciliation and computation
Process
How the work generally proceeds
The sequence varies with the facts and the forum. This is the usual shape of it.
-
Step 01
Identifying the notice
The provision, the period, the amount at issue and the date by which a reply is required.
-
Step 02
Reconstructing the transactions
The invoices, agreements, transport records and payments behind whatever has been questioned.
-
Step 03
Settling the position
What is defensible on the documents, what is not, and where a concession is better made than argued.
-
Step 04
Drafting the reply
Each allegation answered separately, with the document supporting the answer identified against it.
-
Step 05
Filing and representation
The reply is filed within the period and the matter followed through adjudication and, if necessary, appeal.
Preparation
Documents commonly required
Bringing what you have makes the first discussion considerably more useful. Missing items can be obtained later.
- The notice in full, with every annexure and computation attached to it
- GST registration certificate and the returns filed for the period concerned
- Purchase and sales registers for the period, with the invoices in question
- Vendor agreements, transport documents and proof of payment for the supplies at issue
- Reconciliation statements already prepared for the period
- Any earlier reply or correspondence in the same proceeding
Cautions
Common mistakes
- Letting the reply period passWhere a show-cause notice is not answered, the matter proceeds on the department's material. Recovering from that is much harder than replying.
- Replying without the underlying documentsAn assertion that credit was properly taken, unsupported by the invoice, the agreement and the payment, rarely succeeds.
- Answering allegations in bulkEach allegation should be answered separately. A general denial invites a general finding.
- Overlooking the effect on registrationSome proceedings carry consequences for the registration itself, which affects the ability to trade while the matter runs.
- Assuming an appeal will fix itAppeals carry their own conditions, including on deposit. The reply stage is where the record is made.
See also
Related legal and tax services
Reading
Related Guides
General information notes on this area. They are not legal advice.
The practice
Advocates
Each advocate of the firm is enrolled with the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh and holds a Certificate of Practice.
Advocate Hamid Razzaq
- 15+ Years of Legal Experience
- Enrolled with the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh
- Certificate of Practice holder
Advocate Mohd. Mateen
- 20+ Years of Legal Experience
- Enrolled with the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh
- Certificate of Practice holder
Questions
Frequently asked questions
The period is stated on the notice and depends on the provision under which it is issued. It is generally short. Where more time is genuinely required it should be sought before the stated date, not after.
The proceeding will generally continue on the material the department already has, and an order may follow. No outcome can be predicted, but not replying removes your account of the transactions from the record entirely.
Penalty provisions depend on what is alleged and on the findings made, and no amount or outcome is stated on this website. What can be said is that the reply is the stage at which the facts bearing on it are placed on record.
An advocate is among the persons who may act as an authorised representative before the GST authorities. How a particular proceeding is conducted, and whether attendance is required, is confirmed when the matter is taken up.
Where the firm works
Lucknow and Uttar Pradesh Coverage
The firm's office is in Lucknow. Matters arising in other districts of Uttar Pradesh are conducted from Lucknow before the court, tribunal or authority that has jurisdiction over them. There is no branch office elsewhere. Which forum will hear a particular matter depends on its subject, its value and where the cause of action arose, and is confirmed before anything is filed.
This page is general information about an area of practice. It is not legal advice, and it is not an advertisement or a solicitation of work. Reading it creates no advocate–client relationship.
Procedures, limitation periods, court fees, stamp duty and government charges change, and what applies depends on the facts of the particular matter. Nothing here should be acted on without advice on your own documents, and no outcome is promised or predicted.
Last reviewed: